Saatva vs. Birch: Choosing the Perfect Mattress for Your Best Night’s Sleep

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs. See our disclosure page for more information.

Saatva Mattress and the Birch Mattress are Two exceptional contenders in the realm of high-quality mattresses . Both offer a tantalizing blend of comfort, support, and eco-consciousness, but they do so with their unique characteristics and design philosophies. In this comprehensive comparison, we’ll delve deep into the intricacies of these two mattresses to help you make an informed choice.

AspectSaatva RatingsBirch Ratings
Quality and Durability5/54.5/5
Design and Aesthetics4.5/54/5
Price Range4/54.5/5
Customer Reviews4.5/54.5/5
Customer Service5/54.5/5
Comfort Layer4.5/54.5/5
Pocketed Coils5/54.5/5
Motion Transfer4.5/54.5/5
Edge Support4.5/54.5/5
Off Gassing4/54/5
Temperature Neutrality4.5/54.5/5
Back Support4.5/54.5/5
Pressure Relief4.5/54.5/5
People With Back Pain 4.5/54.5/5
Heavy People 4.5/54.5/5
For Couples4.5/54.5/5
Sleep Trial5/54.5/5
Mattress RemovalN/AN/A

Saatva Vs Birch Mattress Compared By Features

Construction and Materials

Saatva Mattress Construction

The Saatva Mattress boasts a construction that exudes luxury and sustainability. Its journey to slumber paradise begins with an organic cotton cover, offering a soft and breathable surface that cradles you into bliss. Just beneath, the Euro pillow top, a hallmark of plushness, greets you with a cloud-like embrace. However, what truly sets Saatva apart is its ingenious use of coils. With dual coil layers – individually wrapped comfort coils and steel support coils – it’s a symphony of support and bounce.

Read The Full Saatva Classic Mattress Review Here

Birch Mattress Construction

Meanwhile, the Birch Mattress subscribes to the ethos of natural goodness. It starts with an organic cotton cover, just like its counterpart, but adds a generous layer of natural wool, a fire-resistant and moisture-wicking marvel. Beneath this, the Talalay latex comfort layer offers responsive support while maintaining a cool temperature. Like Saatva, Birch also relies on coils for its support, creating a harmonious blend of natural and structural excellence.

Comfort and Feel

Saatva Mattress Comfort Options

Saatva showers you with options. You can choose from three different comfort levels – Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm. The Plush Soft is a cloud of coziness for those who prefer sinking into their mattress. Luxury Firm strikes the perfect balance, while the Firm provides robust support for those who need it.

Birch Mattress Comfort and Feel

On the other hand, Birch leans towards the medium-firm end of the spectrum. It offers a universally comfortable feel, catering to a broader audience. The Talalay latex delivers a responsive surface, adapting to your body’s contours and providing that delightful ‘floating’ sensation. It’s an invitation to wake up refreshed every morning.

Support and Durability

Saatva Mattress Support System

Saatva’s support system is a marvel of engineering. The individually wrapped coils contour to your body, providing customized support while isolating motion. Additionally, the robust edge support ensures you can use every inch of your mattress.

Birch Mattress Support and Durability

Birch doesn’t skimp on quality either. Its combination of natural materials and coils promises long-term durability. The reinforced edges mean you can comfortably sit or sleep on the edge without the fear of a sagging border.

Eco-Friendliness and Sustainability

Saatva Mattress Eco-Friendly Features

Saatva takes its eco-responsibility seriously. The organic cotton cover, combined with recycled steel coils, makes it a sustainable choice. You can rest easy knowing your slumber doesn’t come at the expense of the environment.

Birch Mattress Sustainability

Birch, however, pushes the envelope further. It employs natural materials throughout its construction, and the latex is Eco-INSTITUT certified, ensuring low emissions and minimal environmental impact. Birch stands as a testament to the fusion of comfort and conscientiousness.

Motion Isolation

Saatva Mattress Motion Isolation

If you share your bed with a restless sleeper, Saatva’s motion isolation will be your savior. The individually wrapped coils absorb motion, so you can sleep undisturbed even if your partner tosses and turns.

Birch Mattress Motion Isolation

Birch also offers decent motion isolation thanks to its latex and coil system. While it may not be as impeccable as Saatva in this regard, it still ensures a relatively peaceful slumber.

Temperature Regulation

Saatva Mattress Temperature Control

Saatva’s breathable coil system and organic cotton cover contribute to effective temperature regulation. You’ll stay cool even on the warmest nights.

Birch Mattress Temperature Regulation

Birch’s natural wool and latex also play a vital role in temperature control. The wool wicks away moisture, and the latex provides excellent airflow, creating a cool and dry sleep environment.

Price and Value

Saatva Mattress Pricing

Saatva offers excellent value for your investment. The range of comfort options and the quality of materials justify its price point. With the added benefits of a generous trial period and warranty, it’s a compelling choice.

Birch Mattress Pricing

Birch competes with an attractive pricing strategy. Its use of natural materials and craftsmanship make it a steal for eco-conscious consumers. And like Saatva, it provides a trial period and warranty that solidify its value proposition.

Customer Feedback and Reviews

Saatva Mattress Customer Feedback

User experiences with Saatva are a mixed bag. Some users revel in its plushness, while others find it too soft. Edge support and durability receive favorable reviews, but individual preferences play a significant role in overall satisfaction.

Birch Mattress Customer Reviews

Birch garners praise for its comfort and eco-friendliness. Users appreciate the medium-firm feel and the natural materials. It tends to enjoy more consistent positive feedback, making it a reliable choice for a wide range of sleepers.

Who Should Choose Saatva Mattress?

Saatva shines for those who crave a luxurious touch in their sleep. If you have specific comfort preferences – whether it’s a cloud-like embrace or firm support – Saatva’s options cater to your individual taste. Moreover, its eco-conscious construction aligns with a sustainable lifestyle.

Who Should Choose Birch Mattress?

Birch is the go-to choice for eco-warriors seeking an eco-friendly slumber. If you desire a medium-firm feel that suits most sleep styles, Birch’s natural and sustainable construction delivers on all fronts. It’s a mattress for those who prioritize both comfort and a greener footprint.


In the battle of Saatva vs. Birch Mattress, there’s no clear winner – it’s more a matter of personal preference. Saatva excels in luxury and customization, while Birch thrives in eco-consciousness and universality. Your choice depends on what you prioritize in your quest for the perfect night’s sleep. Ultimately, both mattresses stand as shining examples of how innovation and sustainability can coexist in the world of bedding.

Designed for Athletes

Birch Mattress

Beneath the cover, the Birch Mattress boasts a layer of natural wool sourced from New Zealand. Wool acts as a natural temperature regulator, keeping you warm in winter and cool in summer. This layer also provides additional cushioning and support. The mattress is then enhanced with natural Talalay latex, derived from sustainable rubber trees. This latex layer offers responsive support, conforming to your body’s contours and relieving pressure points.

FAQ: Saatva vs. Birch – Choosing the Right Mattress for Your Needs

1. What are Saatva and Birch mattresses? Saatva and Birch are two popular mattress brands known for their high-quality, eco-friendly materials, and thoughtful design. Saatva is a luxury hybrid innerspring mattress, while Birch is a natural and organic hybrid mattress .

2. How do Saatva and Birch mattresses differ in terms of materials? Saatva mattresses use a combination of coils, memory foam, and Euro pillow top, providing excellent support and comfort. On the other hand, Birch mattresses are made with natural materials like organic cotton, natural Talalay latex, and individually wrapped coils for a more eco-friendly approach.

3. Which type of sleeper is each mattress best suited for? Saatva mattresses are suitable for a wide range of sleepers due to their various firmness options, making them great for back, side, and stomach sleepers. Birch mattresses are also versatile and cater to most sleepers, especially those who prefer a more natural and organic sleep surface.

4. Are these mattresses good for back pain relief ? Both Saatva and Birch mattresses are designed to provide good support for your spine, potentially alleviating back pain. However, the best choice for back pain relief depends on individual preferences and needs. Some may find Saatva’s coil system more supportive, while others might prefer Birch’s natural latex and coil combination.

5. Do these mattresses have any eco-friendly certifications? Yes, both Saatva and Birch are committed to sustainability and have earned certain eco-friendly certifications. Saatva uses CertiPUR-US certified foams, while Birch is Greenguard Gold certified, indicating low emissions and a focus on indoor air quality.

6. Can I try these mattresses before purchasing? Saatva is primarily an online brand, so they offer a home trial period during which you can try the mattress and return it if you’re not satisfied. Birch, as a Helix Sleep brand, is also available online with a sleep trial, but they may have showrooms where you can try their mattresses in person.

7. What about warranty and return policies? Both Saatva and Birch offer generous warranty periods. Saatva provides a 15-year warranty, while Birch offers a 25-year warranty. Additionally, they both have hassle-free return policies during their respective sleep trial periods.

8. How do the prices compare? Saatva mattresses tend to be more affordable compared to Birch, but it depends on the specific model and size you choose. Birch’s organic materials and eco-friendly approach might contribute to the slightly higher price tag.

9. Which mattress is better for motion isolation? Both Saatva and Birch perform reasonably well in motion isolation due to their hybrid constructions. However, Saatva’s memory foam layer might provide slightly better motion isolation than Birch’s latex layer.

10. Can you use these mattresses with an adjustable bed frame? Yes, both Saatva and Birch mattresses are compatible with adjustable bed frames. However, it’s essential to check the specific model and size to ensure proper fit and functionality.

Innerspring Hybrid

Saatva Classic Mattress

The Saatva Classic Mattress is our top pick for the best mattress for chronic pain. This mattress combines three zones of memory foam with pocketed coils to create a medium-firm feel that adapts to your body shape and sleeping position.