Amerisleep vs. Casper: The Ultimate Mattress Showdown

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs. See our disclosure page for more information.

In the ever-evolving world of mattresses, two brands have stood out and garnered immense popularity among consumers – Amerisleep and Casper. As sleep plays a crucial role in our overall well-being, choosing the right mattress is of paramount importance. In this comprehensive comparison, we’ll delve deep into the features, technologies, customer reviews, and overall performance of both Amerisleep and Casper mattresses to help you make an informed decision.

Amerisleep Mattress

Experience superior sleep with Amerisleep Mattress. Dive into advanced comfort and support for rejuvenating rest. Upgrade your sleep sanctuary, transform your nights. Discover the perfect blend of innovation and tranquility. Elevate your rest with Amerisleep – where technology meets relaxation. Your path to better sleep starts here!

AspectAmerisleep MattressCasper Mattress
Mattress TypeMemory Foam and Hybrid optionsMemory Foam and Hybrid options
ConstructionMultiple layers of memory foamMultiple layers of memory foam
Firmness OptionsVaries based on modelVaries based on model
SupportContouring support with targeted zonesZoned support with comfort layers
CoolingEnhanced cooling technologiesOpen-cell foam and cooling cover
Motion IsolationExcellent motion isolationGood motion isolation
Edge SupportGood to excellent edge supportAdequate edge support
DurabilityGenerally goodGenerally good
SinkageMinimal to moderateMinimal to moderate
OdorMinimal to moderate off-gassingSome initial off-gassing
Eco-FriendlySome models feature plant-based materialsLimited eco-friendly features
PricingVaries based on model and optionsVaries based on model and options
Warranty10 to 20-year limited warranties10-year limited warranty

1. Mattress Construction


Amerisleep takes pride in using advanced materials to construct their mattresses. Their flagship model, the AS3, is made from plant-based memory foam, known as Bio-Pur®, which is more breathable and eco-friendly compared to traditional memory foam. The AS3 also features an Affinity layer, which provides targeted support to different areas of the body, ensuring proper spinal alignment .


Casper, on the other hand, is renowned for its unique hybrid design. Their mattresses combine various layers, including open-cell foam, memory foam, and pocketed coils, to create a balanced and supportive sleeping surface. The Zoned Support™ technology in Casper mattresses offers enhanced support to different parts of the body, optimizing comfort and alignment.

2. Comfort and Feel


The Amerisleep AS3 offers a medium firmness level, making it suitable for a wide range of sleepers. The Bio-Pur® foam contours to the body, relieving pressure points, and providing a comfortable sleep experience. The mattress has excellent motion isolation, making it ideal for couples or light sleepers who don’t want to be disturbed by movements during the night.


Casper mattresses generally have a medium-firm feel. The combination of foam and pocketed coils provides a responsive surface that offers a balance between contouring and support. The Zoned Support™ technology enhances comfort by providing softer support to the shoulders and firmer support to the hips and lower back.

3. Cooling Technology


Amerisleep mattresses are designed with cooling in mind. The Bio-Pur® foam is infused with cooling materials, allowing for better heat dissipation and temperature regulation. Additionally, the breathable cover promotes airflow, keeping you cool throughout the night.


Casper mattresses also incorporate cooling elements. The open-cell foam used in their construction facilitates airflow, preventing heat retention. The pocketed coil system further aids in dissipating heat, ensuring a cool and comfortable sleep environment.

4. Durability and Longevity


Amerisleep is known for producing high-quality mattresses with exceptional durability. The use of plant-based materials in their foams enhances their resilience and reduces sagging over time. Customers have reported that Amerisleep mattresses maintain their shape and support even after years of use.


Casper mattresses are built to last and have garnered positive reviews for their longevity. The combination of durable foams and pocketed coils ensures that the mattress retains its structural integrity for an extended period. Users have found Casper mattresses to be a reliable investment in terms of durability.

5. Customer Reviews and Reputation


Amerisleep has received widespread acclaim from customers for its exceptional comfort and support. Positive reviews often highlight the effectiveness of the Affinity layer in relieving back pain and the overall quality of sleep experienced on their mattresses.


Casper has built a strong reputation in the mattress industry, with a large customer base praising their products. Positive reviews often mention the perfect balance between comfort and support that Casper mattresses provide, leading to better sleep quality.

AspectAmerisleep MattressCasper Mattress
Motion Isolation★★★★★★★★★☆
Edge Support★★★★☆★★★☆☆
PricingVaries based on model and optionsVaries based on model and options


In conclusion, both Amerisleep and Casper offer high-quality mattresses that cater to different sleep preferences. Amerisleep’s AS3 with its plant-based memory foam and Affinity layer excels in contouring and pressure relief. Casper’s hybrid design, incorporating foam and pocketed coils with Zoned Support™ technology, provides a balanced feel and optimal spinal alignment.

Ultimately, the choice between Amerisleep and Casper depends on individual preferences, comfort needs, and budget considerations. Both brands offer risk-free sleep trials, allowing customers to try out their mattresses and make an informed decision.