Double Pillow Top Mattress Pros & Cons, Benefits & advantages

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs. See our disclosure page for more information.

The pros and cons of a pillowtop mattress present a balanced perspective for potential buyers. On the positive side, these mattresses offer a level of comfort that’s hard to match. The additional padding on top provides a plush, luxurious feel, making them particularly appealing for those who enjoy a soft sleeping surface. They excel at relieving pressure points, catering to individuals with joint or muscle pain. Furthermore, pillowtop mattresses are excellent at motion isolation, ensuring that partners are less likely to disturb each other during the night. However, there are drawbacks to consider.

Hybrid Innerspring

Saatva Classic Mattress

The Saatva Pillow Top Mattress offers luxurious comfort with its extra layer of plush padding atop the already supportive mattress. It provides a cloud-like sleeping surface, enhancing pressure relief and ensuring a restful night’s sleep. Crafted with high-quality materials and expert craftsmanship, the Saatva Pillow Top Mattress combines durability, support, and sumptuous softness, making it an excellent choice for those seeking a premium sleep experience with a touch of opulence.

Over time, the pillowtop layer may lose its shape and become uneven, impacting the mattress’s overall support. Maintenance is also a concern; these mattresses require regular fluffing and rotation to prevent indentations. Additionally, some pillowtop mattresses tend to retain heat, potentially causing discomfort for those who sleep hot. Lastly, their higher cost and substantial weight make them an investment that might not be suitable for everyone’s budget or practicality. Therefore, while offering unparalleled comfort, buyers must carefully weigh these advantages and disadvantages to make an informed decision about their purchase.

Pros and Cons of a Pillowtop Mattress

Pillow top mattress is an improvement on the traditional innerspring mattress which has been in use for many years. Pillow top mattresses add comfort to the innerspring mattress by providing an additional padded layer on top of the mattress. This layer is made from foam or feathers for that extra softness and comfort. But like all products, pillow top mattresses too, have their pros and cons.

Pillow Top Mattresses – Pros

Some of the positive points of pillow top mattresses are

  • The mattresses are quite comfortable and have a soft feel. The extra padding gives more comfort to the person using the mattress. Back and side sleepers are said to benefit more from this mattress.
  • Good support is another positive point in favor of pillow top mattresses
  • A number of users were satisfied with the affordability of the mattress. This is especially true since memory foam mattresses are quite expensive and many customers were able to get the same comfort with the pillow top mattress.
  • A few customers (about 10%) also felt relief from back pain after using this mattress.
  • Many customers were satisfied with the quality of the mattress and its sturdiness

Pillow Top Mattresses – Cons

Some of the negative points of pillow top mattresses are

  • Heat is one of the major complaints about the pillow top mattress. This problem is especially critical when the top layer of the mattress is made of memory foam or other dense materials which radiate heat
  • Price-conscious customers or those with a fixed budget find the pillow top mattresses to be more expensive than innerspring mattresses.
  • If the top layer is not of good quality, the pillow top mattress develops indentations. All soft mattresses which contour to the body of the sleeper do develop indentations, but when they sink deeper than normal, then it is considered a manufacturing defect. The feather of foam on top layer may also shift and cause indents.
  • The pillow top mattresses also require deeper fitted sheets. Since the thickness of the mattress is bigger than the normal standard mattress, the fitted sheets too, need to have deeper pockets for them to fit the mattress
  • A few customers found the pillow top mattress to be too soft

What are the precautions that can be taken to keep the mattress in shape?

Do Pillowtop mattresses need flipping?

Flipping the mattress is one option of reducing the indents or sinking effect. But pillow top mattresses cannot be flipped unless they are quilted on both sides. This makes the mattress very expensive. Also, manufacturers claim that the pillow top mattresses do not need flipping.

Are all pillow top mattresses good?

Not all pillow top mattresses are made from the same material and those made from cheaper foam make the mattresses sink faster. Pillow top mattresses’ top layers have to be made from high-quality memory foam or latex for it to last longer. Double sided pillow top mattresses also last longer since the mattress can be turned over. One sided mattresses need to have quality material for it to last.

How do you choose a good pillow top mattress?

Most of the good and popular brands sell these type of mattresses. Some of them are Sealy Posturepedic, Serta Perfect Sleeper, Simmons Beautyrest Recharge, Restonic Comfort care etc. Most of the mattress makers rename the same type of mattress for different companies with very little variations. Most of the mattresses may have similar features under different brand names. So customers are recommended to go through user reviews and warranty terms to choose the right mattress to suit their needs.

PillowTop Mattresses for Lumbar Support and its downside

When it comes to selecting the ideal mattress, considerations about back health often take precedence. The correlation between mattress types and back support is a critical factor to address. In this section, we will explore the question: Is a pillow-top mattress good for your back?

The Lumbar Support Dilemma

A pivotal aspect of back health lies in the support a mattress provides to the lumbar region. The lumbar spine, or lower back, requires proper alignment during sleep to avoid discomfort and potential long-term issues. Let’s investigate how a pillow-top mattress fares in offering the necessary support to maintain a healthy back.

Pillow Top Mattresses: A Soft Haven with Supportive Features

Contrary to the perception that softer mattresses may be detrimental to back health, pillow-top mattresses come with unique features that cater to both comfort and support. Discover how these mattresses create a soft haven while ensuring that the crucial lumbar region receives the support it needs.

The Balance of Comfort and Spinal Alignment

One of the distinguishing factors of pillow-top mattresses is their ability to strike a balance between comfort and spinal alignment . Explore how the additional padding on the surface provides a plush feel without compromising the crucial alignment of the spine, contributing to a more comfortable and back-friendly sleep experience.

Addressing Back Pain: A Personalized Approach

Individuals who experience back pain often seek mattresses that alleviate discomfort and promote healing. Pillow-top mattresses, with their tailored support and cushioning, can be part of a personalized approach to addressing back pain. Understand how these mattresses contribute to a more conducive sleeping environment for those dealing with back-related issues.

Potential Considerations for Back Sleepers

While pillow-top mattresses offer a blend of comfort and support, there are considerations for specific sleeping preferences. Back sleepers, in particular, may find certain features of pillow-top mattresses more beneficial. Delve into the considerations that back sleepers should keep in mind when contemplating a pillow-top mattress for optimal back support.

Pillowtop Mattress Durability concerns

Investing in a mattress is a significant decision, and understanding its lifespan is crucial for long-term satisfaction and value. In this section, we will delve into the question: What is the lifespan of a pillow-top mattress?

Durability and Material Composition

The lifespan of a pillow-top mattress is influenced by several factors, with the composition of materials playing a key role. Explore how the materials used in the construction of a pillow-top mattress contribute to its overall durability and longevity.

Quality Matters: Evaluating Construction and Craftsmanship

The craftsmanship and construction of a pillow-top mattress are paramount in determining its lifespan. Quality manufacturing ensures that the additional padding and layers are securely integrated, contributing to a mattress that stands the test of time. Delve into the aspects of construction and craftsmanship that impact the durability of a pillow-top mattress.

Wear and Tear: Managing Everyday Use

Like any other piece of furniture, a mattress undergoes wear and tear over time. Factors such as daily usage, weight distribution, and maintenance play roles in determining how well a pillow-top mattress holds up. Explore how to manage everyday use to optimize the lifespan of your mattress.

Flipping and Rotating: Maintenance Strategies

Pillow-top mattresses often have specific recommendations regarding flipping and rotating to maintain even wear. Understand the importance of following these guidelines and how such maintenance practices can extend the lifespan of your pillow-top mattress.

Warranty Insights: A Glimpse into Expected Lifespan

Manufacturers often provide warranties that offer insights into the expected lifespan of a pillow-top mattress. Examine common warranty terms, what they cover, and how they can serve as indicators of the manufacturer’s confidence in the durability of their product.

Signs of Wear: Knowing When It’s Time for a Replacement

Despite the best efforts to care for a pillow-top mattress, there comes a time when signs of wear become apparent. Recognizing these signs is essential for knowing when it’s time to consider a replacement. Learn about the common indicators that suggest your pillow-top mattress may have reached the end of its lifespan.

Frequently Asked Questions – Pillow Top Mattress

What is a Pillow Top mattress?

A Pillow Top mattress is a type of mattress that features an additional layer of soft padding sewn onto the top surface. This layer, often made of memory foam, latex, or plush materials, provides extra cushioning and a luxurious, pillow-like feel.

What are the benefits of a Pillow Top mattress?

Pillow Top mattresses offer several benefits, including enhanced comfort, pressure point relief, and added support. The extra layer of padding provides a plush surface that conforms to your body, promoting better spinal alignment and reducing discomfort.

Are Pillow Top mattresses suitable for all sleeping positions? Yes, Pillow Top mattresses are designed to accommodate various sleeping positions. The soft padding conforms to your body’s contours, regardless of whether you sleep on your back, side, or stomach. However, it’s essential to choose a Pillow Top mattress with adequate support to ensure proper alignment.

Can I use a Pillow Top mattress with an adjustable bed frame?

Yes, many Pillow Top mattresses are compatible with adjustable bed frames. However, it’s crucial to check the mattress specifications to ensure it can bend and flex without damaging the Pillow Top layer or the overall mattress structure.

Do Pillow Top mattresses require special care?

Pillow Top mattresses don’t require any specific care beyond regular mattress maintenance. It’s recommended to rotate the mattress every few months to promote even wear and prolong its lifespan. Additionally, using a mattress protector can help keep the Pillow Top layer clean and protect it from stains.

Are Pillow Top mattresses suitable for individuals with back pain ?

Pillow Top mattresses can be beneficial for individuals with back pain. The extra layer of cushioning helps alleviate pressure points and provides additional support to the body, which can help reduce discomfort and promote a more restful sleep.

Do Pillow Top mattresses sleep hot?

Pillow Top mattresses can retain some heat due to the additional padding and materials used. However, many manufacturers incorporate cooling technologies, such as breathable covers or gel-infused foam, to mitigate heat retention and promote a cooler sleeping environment.

Can I use a regular bed frame with a Pillow Top mattress?

Yes, Pillow Top mattresses are compatible with most regular bed frames, including platform beds, box springs, or slatted frames. Ensure that the bed frame provides adequate support and doesn’t have large gaps that could affect the mattress’s stability or comfort.

How long does a Pillow Top mattress typically last?

The lifespan of a Pillow Top mattress can vary depending on the quality of materials and usage. On average, a well-maintained Pillow Top mattress can last between 7 to 10 years. Proper care, including regular rotation and using a mattress protector, can help extend its longevity.

Can I try a Pillow Top mattress before buying?

Yes, it’s often possible to try out Pillow Top mattresses in physical stores or showrooms. Additionally, many online mattress retailers offer generous trial periods, allowing you to test the mattress in the comfort of your own home and return it if you’re not satisfied.